基于系统动力学的城市生活垃圾发电进化博弈

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1007-7375.e16-3097

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 为了降低垃圾焚烧发电所导致的环境污染，促使垃圾焚烧发电厂在垃圾处理过程中采取绿色无害化处理，基于有限理性的假设，运用进化博弈论来分析中央政府、地方政府和垃圾焚烧发电企业三方在生活垃圾处理过程中的决策，建立三方进化博弈模型，并运用系统动力学对三方进化博弈过程进行动态模拟仿真。仿真结果表明，三方的策略选择反复波动，不存在进化稳定策略。因此，引入动态惩罚和动态奖励策略试图对波动进行控制。通过仿真发现，动态惩罚可以有效地抑制波动，使三方的策略选择趋于稳定。通过敏感性分析，分别提高对地方政府和企业的最高惩罚标准。通过比较发现，提高企业的最高处罚标准不仅可以有效地抑制波动，还可以有效提高垃圾焚烧发电企业实行垃圾绿色处理的概率，使之趋近于1。

关键词: 城市生活垃圾管理, 进化博弈, 进化稳定策略, 系统动力学, 复制动态

Abstract: Based on the assumption of bounded rationality, an evolutionary game model is proposed to analyze the decision among the central government, local government and MSW incineration power enterprises in waste disposing process while trying to reduce the environment pollution caused by municipal solid waste (MSW) incineration with electricity generation and promote MSW incineration power enterprises to dispose the waste in a green process. System dynamics is applied to analyze the stability of three stakeholders and identify equilibrium solutions. The simulation results show that the strategy selections of the three stakeholders fluctuate repeatedly, which indicates that the evolutionary stable strategy does not exist among the stakeholders. Therefore, dynamic penalty and dynamic reward are proposed to control the fluctuations. According to the sensitivity analysis, the simulation results indicate that the dynamic penalty can effectively restrain the fluctuations and make stakeholders more stable. Furthermore, compared with raising local government maximum penalty standard, raising the enterprise maximum penalty standard can not only restrain the fluctuations effectively but also present an ideal evolutionary stable strategy in which the probability of MSW incineration power enterprises to increase their probability to dispose waste in green process is closed to 1.

Key words: municipal solid waste management, evolutionary game, evolutionary stable strategy, system dynamics, replicator dynamics

中图分类号:

F205

代峰, 戴伟. 基于系统动力学的城市生活垃圾发电进化博弈[J]. 工业工程, 2017, 20(1): 1-11.

DAI Feng, DAI Wei. Analysis of an Evolutionary Game under Municipal Solid Waste Incineration Power Generation Based on System Dynamics[J]. Industrial Engineering Journal , 2017, 20(1): 1-11.

参考文献

[1] 中华人民共和国国家统计局. 中国统计年鉴[M]. 北京:中国统计出版社, 2004-2015. National Bureau of Statistics of the People's Republic of China. China statistical yearbook[M]. Beijing:China Statistics Press, 2004-2015.
[2] 唐龙, 唐一科. 垃圾发电产业化的一些问题及解决思路[J]. 生态经济, 2007, 23(7):114-116 TANG Long, TANG Yike. Problems in the industrialization of refuse incineration-power generation and possible solutions[J]. Ecological Economy, 2007,23(7):114-116.
[3] 中国砂石协会. "十三五"垃圾处理设施水平待提高[EB/OL](2016-03-04). http://www.zgss.org.cn/zixun/zhuti/1446.html.
[4] 熊孟清. 从"十三五"规划建议看我国垃圾处理转变[N]. 中国建设报, 2015-12-03(2).
[5] PETTS J. Incineration risk perceptions and public concern:experience in the UK improving risk communication[J]. Waste Management & Resarch, 1992, 10(2):169-182
[6] KALMYKOVA Y, FEDJE K K. Phosphorus recovery from municipal solid waste incineration fly ash[J]. Waste Management, 2013, 33(6):1403-1410
[7] FEDJE K K, EKBERG C, SKARNEMARK G, et al. Initial studies of the recovery of Cu from MSWI fly ash leachates using solvent extraction[J]. Waste Management & Research, 2012, 30(10):1072-1080.
[8] SCHLUMBERGER S, BUEHLER J. Urban mining:metal recovery from fly and filter ash in waste to energy plants[C]. Stockholm, Sweden:ASH 2012.
[9] BEYLOT A, VILLENEUVE J. Environmental impacts of residual municipal solid waste incineration:a comparison of 110 French incinerators using a life cycle approach[J]. Waste Management, 2013, 33(12):2781-2788.
[10] BOZORGIRAD M A, Hao Zhang, Karl R Haapala. et al. Murthy. Environmental impact and cost assessment of incineration and ethanol production as municipal solid waste management strategies[J]. The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, 2013, 18(8):1502-1512.
[11] NIXONA J D, WRIGHT D G, DEY P K, et al. A comparative assessment of waste incinerators in the UK[J]. Waste Management, 2013, 33(11):2234-2244
[12] 俞祖成, 庄秀娟. 我国公共决策中的利益诉求与利益博弈分析——以"番禺垃圾焚烧事件"为例[J]. 广东广播电视大学学报, 2010, 19(81):64-70 YU Zucheng, ZHANG Xiujuan. The interests demands of the public decision-making and interests of the game——based on the panyu waste incineration incident[J]. Journal of Guangdong radio & TV University, 2010, 19(81):64-70.
[13] 刘承毅, 王建明. 声誉激励、社会监督与质量规制——城市垃圾处理行业中的博弈分析[J]. 产经评论, 2014,5(2):93-106. LIU Chengyi, WANG Jianming. Reputation incentive, social supervision and quality regulation——game analysis in the waste disposal industry[J]. Industrial Economic Review, 2014,5(2):93-106.
[14] 李郁芳, 邱丹平. 基于利益集团理论的垃圾焚烧发电问题分析[J]. 生态经济, 2010, 26(10):149-152. LI Yufang, QIU Danping. The analysis of refuse incinerating power generation problem from the perspective of interest groups[J]. Ecological Economy, 2010, 26(10):149-152.
[15] SMITH J M, PRICE G R. The logic of animal conflict[J]. Nature, 1973, 246(5427):15-18
[16] SELTEN R. Evolutionary stability in extensive two-person games[J]. Mathematical Social Sciences, 1983, 5(3):269-363.
[17] HIRSHLEIFER J. Evolutionary models in economics and law:cooperative versus conflict strategies[J]. Research in Law and Economics, 1982(4):1-60
[18] FRIEDMAN D. Economic applications of evolutionary game theory[J]. Journal of Evolutionary Economics, 1998, 8(1):15-43.
[19] TAYLOR P D, JONKER L B. Evolutionarily stable strategy and game dynamics[J]. Math Bioscience, 1978, 40(1-2):145-156.
[20] 孙庆文, 陆柳, 严广乐, 等. 不完全信息条件下演化博弈均衡的稳定性分析[J]. 系统工程理论与实践, 2003, 23(7):11-16. SUN Qingwen, LU Liu, YAN Guangle. Asymptotic stability of evolutionary equilibrium under imperfect knowledge[J]. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice, 2003, 23(7):11-16.
[21] 邱中华, 金栩. 基于进化博弈论研究一类监查博弈[J]. 南京邮电大学学报(自然科学版), 2006, 26(5):46-49. QIU Zhonghua, JIN Xu. Study on a supervisory game based on evolutionary game theory[J]. Journal of Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications(Natural Science Edition), 2006, 26(5):46-49.
[22] 蔡玲如, 王红卫, 曾伟. 基于系统动力学的环境污染演化博弈问题研究[J]. 计算机科学, 2009, 36(8):234-238. CAI Lingru, WANG Hongwei, ZENG Wei. System dynamics model for a mixed-strategy game of environmental pollution[J]. Computer Science, 2009, 36(8):234-238.
[23] 达庆利, 张骥骧. 有限理性条件下进化博弈均衡的稳定性分析[J]. 系统工程理论方法应用, 2006, 15(3):279-284. DA Qingli, ZHANG Jixiang. Stability of evolutionary equilibrium under bounded rationality[J]. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice, 2006, 15(3):279-284.
[24] 魏芳芳, 陈福集. 三方非对称进化博弈行为分析[J]. 浙江大学学报(理学版), 2013, 40(2):146-151. WEI Fangfang, CHEN Fuji. A behavior analysis of evolutionary game under three asymmetric parties[J].Journal of Zhejiang University(Science Edition), 2013, 40(2):146-151.
[25] 刘连光, 刘鸿熹, 刘自发, 等. 新能源接入下风火网三方非对称进化博弈分析[J]. 中国科学:技术科学, 2015, 45(12):1297-1303. LIU Lianguang, LIU Hongxi, LIU Zifa, et al. Analysis of tripartite asymmetric evolutionary game among wind power enterprises, thermal power enterprises and power grid enterprises under new energy resources integrated[J]. Scienta Sinica Techologica, 2015, 45(12):1297-1303.
[26] 特日昆, 徐飞. 战略性新兴产业信贷融资问题研究——基于银政企三方进化博弈视角[J]. 管理现代化, 2015, 35(6):22-24. TE Rikun, XU Fei. Research on credit financing of strategic emerging industries-based on the perspective of the evolution game three-side among bank, government and enterprises[J]. Modernization of Management, 2015, 35(6):22-24.
[27] 朱庆华, 窦一杰. 绿色供应链中政府与核心企业进化博弈模型[J]. 系统工程理论与实践, 2007, 27(12):85-95. ZHU Qinghua, DOU Yijie. An evolutionary model between governments and core-enterprises in green supply chains[J]. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice, 2007, 27(12):85-95.
[28] 章辉美, 邓子纲. 基于政府、企业、社会三方动态博弈的企业社会责任分析[J]. 系统工程, 2011, 29(6):123-126. ZHANG Huimei, DENG Zigang. Analysis of corporate social responsibility based on three-side dynamic game between government, society and enterprises[J]. Systems Engineering, 2011, 29(6):123-126.
[29] 刘豹, 唐万生. 现代控制理论[M]. 北京:机械工业出版社, 2006.
[30] LIU Quanlong, LI Xinchun, HASSALL M. Evolutionary game analysis and stability control scenarios of coal mine safety inspection system in China based on system dynamics[J].Safety Science, 2015, 80:13-22.
[31] 朱庆华, 王一雷, 田一辉. 基于系统动力学的地方政府与制造企业碳减排演化博弈分析[J]. 运筹与管理, 2014, 23(3):71-82. ZHU Qinghua, WANG Yilei, TIAN Yihui. Analysis of an evolutionary game between local governments and manufacturing enterprises under carbon reduction policies based on system dynamics[J]. Operations Research and Management Science, 2014, 23(3):71-82.