基于眼动数据分析的安检视觉搜索特征

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 目前视觉搜索的相关研究对细节关注甚少。安检是一项特殊的视觉搜索过程，了解其工作过程对改善其工作质量意义重大，因此，有必要对其细节进行研究。选取两组被试进行安检模拟实验，以研究现行安检原则“先难后易，先复杂后简单”的可行性以及两组被试视觉特征的差异。结合两组被试的特点，对数据进行了筛选、统计，运用非参数检验综合分析了两组被试实验数据的差异，并应用专家打分法分析两组被试视觉搜索过程的差异。结果表明，两组被试在注视时间百分比、眼跳距离、判断正确率上存在显著差异，安检员组的正确率比学生组高287%；安检员组的注视持续时间较短，有超过75%的注视点持续时间小于200 ms，而学生组处于该时间段的注视点只占17%左右；安检员组在模拟实验中倾向于遵循安检原则进行系统搜索，而学生组倾向于随机搜索。

关键词: 眼动, 视觉搜索, 经验水平

Abstract: Currently, little attention is paid on the details of the research on visual search. Security screening is a special visual search process, and understanding this process is the premise of improvement. It is necessary to learn the visual search details in security screening. To test the rationality of the current security principle (from difficult to easy, from complex to simple) and the difference between the two groups, two groups (screener's group and students group) are selected to conduct a screening simulation experiment. Based on statistical analysis, by combining with the characteristics of the two groups, a nonparametric test is applied to analyze the differences on some parameters. Expert grading method is used to analyze the searching process. Results reveal that there are significant differences on fixation time percent, saccade distance, and judgment accuracy between the two groups. The screeners correct rate is 28.7% higher than student's, while screeners fixation duration is shorter. There are more than 75% of the fixation points lasting for less than 200 ms, while student's is about 17%. The screener's group tends to do systemic searching under the principle of screening, while the student's group prefers random searching.

Key words: eye movements, visual search, experience level

靳慧斌，蔡亚敏，洪远. 基于眼动数据分析的安检视觉搜索特征[J]. 工业工程, 2014, 17(2): 43-48.

Jin Hui-bin，Cai Ya-min，Hong Yuan . Characteristics of Visual Search in Security Screening Based on Analysis of Eye Movement Data[J]. Industrial Engineering Journal , 2014, 17(2): 43-48.

参考文献

［1］Fiedler E R, Della Rocco P S, Schroeder D J, et al. The Relationship between Aviators’Home based Stress to Work Stress and Self perceived Performance［M］. Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, U. S.:U. S. Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Civil Aero medical Institute,2000. ［2］梁文娟，程明.基于因子分析的民航从业人员职业压力研究［J］.中国安全生产科学技术，2008，4(6): 91-94. 〖DW〗Liang Wenjuan, Cheng Ming. Research on workrelated stress of civil aviation personnel based on factor analysis［J］. Journal of Safety Science and Technology, 2008,4(6):91-94. ［3］Dillingham G L. Aviation security: slow progress in addressing longstanding screener performance problems［R］.Washington DC: Testimony Presented before the Subcommittee on Aviation, Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure, House of Representatives, 2000. ［4］Wolfe J M,Oliva A, Horowitz T S, et al. Segmentation of objects from backgrounds in visual search tasks［J］.Vision Research,2002,42(28): 29853004. ［5］Verghese P, McKee S P. Visual search in clutter［J］. Vision Research,2004,44(12):1217-1225. ［6］Neider M B, Zelinsky G J. Searching for camouflaged targets: effects of targetbackground similarity on visual search［J］. Vision Research, 2006,46(14):2217-2235. ［7］Over E A B， Hooge I T C, Vlaskamp B N S, et al. Coarsetofine eye movement strategy in visual search［J］. Vision Research,2007,47（17）:2272-2280. ［8］Najemnik J, Geisler W S. Optimal eye movement strategies in visual search［J］. Nature,2005, 434(7031):387-391. ［9］Araujo C, Kowler E, Pavel M. Eye movements during visual search: The costs of choosing the optimal path［J］. Vision Research,2001,41(2526): 36133625. ［10］Goonetilleke R S, Lau W C, Shih H M. Visual search strategies and eye movements when searching Chinese character screens［J］. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies,2002, 57(6): 447-468. ［11］OjanpH, Nasanen R, Kojo I. Eye movements in the visual search of word lists［J］. Vision Research,2002, 42(12): 1499-1512. ［12］Christ S E, Abrams R A. Abrupt onsets cannot be ignored［J］. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review,2006, 13(5): 875-880. ［13］袁伟，付锐，马勇,等.车速与标志文字高度对驾驶人视觉搜索模式的影响［J］. 交通运输工程学报，2011，24（1）：119126. Yuan Wei, Fu Rui, Ma Yong， et al. Effects of vehicle speed and traffic sign text height on drivers’ visual search patterns ［J］. Journal of Traffic and Transportation Engineering, 2011, 24(1):119-126. ［14］刘杰，饶培伦. 针对网页视觉设计的视觉搜索能力研究［J］. 人类工效学，2006，12(2)：1-3. Liu Jie, Rau Pei luen Patrick. A study on the user visual search performances for web visual design［J］. Chinese Journal of Ergonomics, 2006, 12(2):1-3. ［15］石金富，曹晓华，王钢. 网页布局对视觉搜索影响的眼动研究［J］. 人类工效学，2008，14（4）：1-3. Shi Jin-fu, Cao Xiao-hua, Wang Gang. An eye movement study on visual search of web page layout［J］. Chinese Journal of Ergonomics, 2008,14(4):1-3. ［16］Smith J D, Redford J S, Washburn D A. Specifictoken effects in screening tasks: possible implications for aviation security ［J］. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 2005, 31(6):1171-1185. ［17］Wolfe J M, Horowitz T S, Kenner N M. Rare items often missed in visual searches［J］.Nature, 2005, 435(1):439450.  ［18］McCarley J S, Kramer A F, Wickens C D, et al. Visual skills in airport security screening［J］. Psychological Science, 2004,15(5): 302-306. ［19］黄迎秋. 山区与城市道路交通环境下驾驶员视觉搜索过程分析［D］. 陕西：长安大学，2008. ［20］张仙峰，叶文玲. 当前阅读研究中眼动指标述评［J］. 心理与行为研究，2006，4（3）：236-240. Zhang Xian-feng, Ye Wen-ling. Review of oculomotor measures in current reading research［J］. Studies of Psychology and Behavior, 2006,4(3):236-240. ［21］柳忠起，袁修干，刘伟,等. 飞行员注意力分配的定量测量方法［J］. 北京航空航天大学学报，2006，32（5）：518-521. Liu Zhong-qi, Yuan Xiu-gan, Liu Wei, et al. Quantitative measuring method of pilots’ attention allocation ［J］. Journal of Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, 2006,32(5):518-521. ［22］Tagare H D, Toyama K, Wang J G. A maximumlikelihood strategy for directing attention during visual search［J］. IEEE Transactions on Parrern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 2001, 23(5):490-500. ［23］Dewar R E, Olson P L. Human factor in traffic safety［M］.Tucson: Lawyers and Judges Publishing Company, Inc, 2001. ［24］Underwood G, Chapman P. Driving experience attentional focusing and the recall of recently inspected events［J］.Transportation Research, 2003, 6(4):289-304. ［25］Underwood G, Chapman P, Bpwdem K, et al. Visual search while driving:skill and awareness during inspection of the scene［J］.Transportation Research,2002,5(4):87-97. ［26］Megaw E D, Richardson J. Eye movements and industrial inspection［J］. Applied Ergonomics，1979, 10(3):145-154. ［27］Drury C G. Visual search in industrial inspection［M］∥Brogan D. Visual Search. London: Taylor and Francis, 1990:19.

[1]	徐新然, 郭肖亚, 于瑞峰. Gap效应对搜索目标显著性和绩效的影响[J]. 工业工程, 2021, 24(1): 117-122.
[2]	贾佳, 杨强, 蒋玉石. 产品页面中推送产品缩略图位置对消费者注意和记忆的影响研究[J]. 工业工程, 2019, 22(4): 40-48.
[3]	刘娜, 张运红, 于瑞峰, 张高艳. 动态视觉搜索任务中显示移动速度对视觉疲劳的影响[J]. 工业工程, 2017, 20(2): 51-55.
[4]	杨林栋1，宋馥璇1，张运红2，于瑞峰1. 目标出现概率、目标有无和时间压力对视觉搜索绩效的影响[J]. 工业工程, 2016, 19(6): 83-88.
[5]	杨林栋，于瑞峰. 人格特征和任务难度对视觉搜索绩效的影响[J]. 工业工程, 2016, 19(1): 91-96.
[6]	高扬，温宝琴. 基于极小值原理的最优眼动控制模型[J]. 工业工程, 2014, 17(6): 12-16.
[7]	杨林栋，刘厚，于瑞峰. 视野培训对视觉搜索绩效的影响[J]. 工业工程, 2014, 17(3): 108-113.
[8]	于瑞峰，程屿晨. 地铁安检作业环境调查与改善的实证研究[J]. 工业工程, 2013, 16(1): 14-18.